Indianapolis Colts Draft History
Indianapolis Colts 2026 season: schedule, results and stat leaders →
655 total draft picks | 61 first-round picks | 1967–2026
Since 1980, the Indianapolis Colts franchise has drafted 432 players in the NFL Draft, 44 of them in the first round. 6 of those picks are in the Pro Football Hall of Fame: John Elway (1983), Marshall Faulk (1994), Marvin Harrison (1996), Peyton Manning (1998), Edgerrin James (1999) and Dwight Freeney (2002). By career Approximate Value, the most productive pick was Peyton Manning (QB, Tennessee), taken in round 1 of the 1998 draft. The biggest value pick was Robert Mathis, a round-5 selection in 2003 who made 5 Pro Bowls. Of the picks made through 2025, 36 (8%) made at least one Pro Bowl and 84% appeared in at least one NFL game. The most common school was USC, with 14 picks.
Figures cover the 1980–2026 drafts. Source: nflverse.
Top Career Totals Among Indianapolis Colts Draft Picks
Full NFL career totals (all teams) for players this team drafted in 1980 or later. Source: nflverse.
All Draft Picks
First Round Picks (61)
Shop Indianapolis Colts Gear
As an Amazon Associate, NFL Records earns from qualifying purchases. Links open Amazon in a new tab.