Every No. 1 Overall Pick From 1980 to 2023, Ranked by Career Value

By NFL Records · Updated October 18, 2026

Being the first player taken guarantees nothing. Of the 44 No. 1 overall picks from 1980 through 2023, 31 made at least one Pro Bowl and 5 reached the Hall of Fame. Quarterbacks account for 24 of them.

The median No. 1 pick in this period finished with a career AV of 64.5.

RankPlayerPosYearTeamCollegeGamesPro BowlsCareer AV
1Peyton ManningQB1998Indianapolis ColtsTennessee26614176
2Bruce SmithDE1985Buffalo BillsVirginia Tech27911152
3John ElwayQB1983Baltimore ColtsStanford2349140
4Matthew StaffordQB2009Detroit LionsGeorgia2443133
5Eli ManningQB2004San Diego ChargersMississippi2364121
6Cam NewtonQB2011Carolina PanthersAuburn1483115
7Carson PalmerQB2003Cincinnati BengalsUSC1823107
8Jared GoffQB2016Los Angeles RamsCalifornia1565106
9Drew BledsoeQB1993New England PatriotsWashington St.1944105
10Orlando PaceT1997St. Louis RamsOhio St.1697104
11Myles GarrettDE2017Cleveland BrownsTexas A&M1357104
12Alex SmithQB2005San Francisco 49ersUtah174398
13Vinny TestaverdeQB1987Tampa Bay BuccaneersMiami (FL)233297
14Troy AikmanQB1989Dallas CowboysUCLA165696
15Michael VickQB2001Atlanta FalconsVirginia Tech143492
16Irving FryarWR1984New England PatriotsNebraska255580
17Baker MayfieldQB2018Cleveland BrownsOklahoma126280
18Keyshawn JohnsonWR1996New York JetsUSC167379
19Mario WilliamsDE2006Houston TexansNorth Carolina St.158479
20Andrew LuckQB2012Indianapolis ColtsStanford86472
21Kyler MurrayQB2019Arizona CardinalsOklahoma91271
22Jeff GeorgeQB1990Indianapolis ColtsIllinois131066
23Jadeveon ClowneyDE2014Houston TexansSouth Carolina156363
24Jameis WinstonQB2015Tampa Bay BuccaneersFlorida St.112163
25Joe BurrowQB2020Cincinnati BengalsLSU82363
26Eric FisherT2013Kansas City ChiefsCentral Michigan132262
27Russell MarylandDT1991Dallas CowboysMiami (FL)154160
28Dan WilkinsonDT1994Cincinnati BengalsOhio St.195060
29Billy SimsRB1980Detroit LionsOklahoma60358
30Jake LongT2008Miami DolphinsMichigan104454
31Trevor LawrenceQB2021Jacksonville JaguarsClemson82152
32George RogersRB1981New Orleans SaintsSouth Carolina92246
33David CarrQB2002Houston TexansFresno St.94045
34Sam BradfordQB2010St. Louis RamsOklahoma83044
35Kenneth SimsDE1982New England PatriotsTexas74031
36Tim CouchQB1999Cleveland BrownsKentucky62030
37Courtney BrownDE2000Cleveland BrownsPenn St.61027
38Travon WalkerDE2022Jacksonville JaguarsGeorgia68026
39Aundray BruceLB1988Atlanta FalconsAuburn151024
40Bryce YoungQB2023Carolina PanthersAlabama50023
41Bo JacksonRB1986Tampa Bay BuccaneersAuburn38122
42Steve EmtmanDE1992Indianapolis ColtsWashington50013
43Ki-Jana CarterRB1995Cincinnati BengalsPenn St.59011
44JaMarcus RussellQB2007Oakland RaidersLSU3106

Data: nflverse draft data (compiled from Pro Football Reference), 1980–2026 drafts. Career outcomes are only compared for classes through 2023, since more recent players are still early in their careers. "Approximate Value" (AV) is Pro Football Reference's single-number estimate of a player's career contribution; it is useful for comparing careers across positions but is not a precise measure. Updated October 18, 2026.