Quick Answer
The best #1 overall pick in NFL history is widely considered to be Peyton Manning (1998, Colts) or John Elway (1983, Colts), both Hall of Famers who won multiple Super Bowls.
Who is the Best Number 1 Overall Pick in NFL History?
The best #1 overall pick in NFL history is widely considered to be Peyton Manning, selected by the Indianapolis Colts in 1998. Manning had one of the greatest NFL careers ever, winning 5 MVP awards, 2 Super Bowls, and setting numerous passing records during his 18-year career.
Other legendary #1 overall picks include:
- John Elway (1983, Colts/Broncos) – 2× Super Bowl champion, Hall of Famer
- Troy Aikman (1989, Cowboys) – 3× Super Bowl champion, Hall of Famer
- Eli Manning (2004, Chargers/Giants) – 2× Super Bowl MVP
- Cam Newton (2011, Panthers) – NFL MVP in 2015
- Joe Burrow (2020, Bengals) – Led Bengals to Super Bowl in year 2
While opinions vary, Peyton Manning's combination of longevity, statistical dominance, and championships makes him the consensus choice for best #1 pick of all time.